REGULAR MEETING, THE SCHOOL BOARD OF BREVARD COUNTY

May 9, 2006

 

The School Board of Brevard County, Florida met in regular session on Tuesday, May 9, 2006, at 5:30 p.m., at the Educational Services Facility, 2700 Judge Fran Jamieson Way, Viera, Florida.  Notice of the meeting was advertised in The Eagle newspaper on Thursday, May 4, 2006 and the affidavit of publication with a copy of the ad attached is filed in supplemental minute book #214, page 214-1.

 

OPENING EXERCISES

Chairman Robert Jordan called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.

 

Members Present:  Robert Jordan, Janice Kershaw, Larry Hughes, Amy Kneessy, Bea Fowler

 

The Invocation was led by Margaret Mueth, 6th Grade, Tropical Elementary School, and the Pledge of Allegiance was led by William Bragan, 6th Grade, Tropical Elementary School.

 

Tropical Elementary School’s 5th grade Choral Ensemble and Choirchimes, under the direction of teacher Theresa Stricker, entertained the board.

 

ADOPTION OF AGENDA

A motion was made by Larry Hughes with a second by Janice Kershaw to approve the recommendations for the revisions to the agenda.  The motion carried unanimously.

 

The following changes were then made to the agenda:

 

Additions:

E-17.    Viera High School - FPL Easements – Two (2) for Main Campus and Stadium/Lift Station

G-1.      Proposed Agreement with Brevard County Commission Regarding Charter School Educational Impact Fees

G-2.      Lewis Carroll Elementary School

H-18.    Renewal of Consulting Agreement with Robert L. Donaldson, Sr.

H-19.    Participation in American Productivity and Quality Center (APQC) and Other Benchmarking Activities

H-20.    Reorganization of the Office of Early Childhood Education and Title I

 

Revisions:

E-1.      Student Expulsions

E-11.    Instructional Staff Recommendations (Supplement)

F-21.    Prototype Design Services for New Elementary School “T”

 

Deletions:

B-7.      NAEYC Accreditation Presentation

H-17.    Lewis Carroll Elementary School

 

B.        RECOGNITION OF VISITORS/GUESTS - AWARDS

B-1.     2006 Outstanding Assistant Principal and Principal Achievement Award for Outstanding Leadership

            Dr. DiPatri recognized the Outstanding Assistant Principals nominated from each level:  Samantha Lambert, Meadowlane Elementary, Sherri Bowman, Kennedy Middle, Tom Armstrong, Eau Gallie High, and recognize the following principals nominated for the Principal Achievement Award for Outstanding Leadership:  Larry Kuhn, Holland Elementary, Rosette Brown, McNair Magnet Middle, and John Thomas, Palm Bay High.  Robert Jordan presented each with a plaque.

 

B-2.     Recognize BPS-TV’s for a SUNSPRA Award

            Dr. DiPatri recognized BPS-TV’s student produced news program called BPS News which garnered a top award as the best Broadcast Public Information Program in the state from SUNSPRA, the Sunshine State School Public Relations Association.  Being recognized were Scott Carrico, BPS-TV Station Manager, Bonnie Tucker, Melbourne High School Video Production teacher, and students Brooks Pipher, Jeleesa Joseph, Alicia Abbott and Shannon McTaggert.  Chairman Jordan presented a plaque to the group.

 

 

 

B-3.     Recognize Brevard Public Schools’ Web Team for Being Awarded the Best Website in the State

            Dr. DiPatri recognized the Brevard Public Schools web team whose website recently was named the best school district website in the state of Florida from SUNSPRA, the Sunshine State School Public Relations Association.  Recognized were Russell Alarie, Lynn Clifton, Ginger Wright, Gail Hannas, Liz Sivco, Sara Stern and Andrea Young.  Chairman Jordan presented a plaque to the group.

 

B-4.     Recognize Edgewood Jr./Sr. High School Future Educators of America Students

            Evelyn Henville, Director of Recruitment and Retention, recognized Edgewood Jr./Sr. High students Kathy Augustine for winning 1st place in the high school essay competition in the Florida Future Educators of America State Conference held on January 6-8, 2006 in Orlando.  Kathy Augustine was also elected as the State Vice-President-Elect for the Student Board.  Ms. Henville also recognized Christina Scates for being selected as the 1st place winner in the high school lesson plan competition, and Cybill Shaffer fro being selected as the 2nd place winner.

 

B-5.     Recognize Businesses and Students Who Have Participated in the Brevard Future Educators of America Club Business Partnership Scholarship Program

            Evelyn Henville, Director of Recruitment and Retention, recognized Kathryn Castellan Mentillo for winning the Community Educators Credit Union scholarship and her advisor Lindsey Dooley.  She also recognized student Nicole Scala for winning the Riverside National Bank’s scholarship.  Barbara Bailey of Riverside Bank and Nicole’s advisor, accepted the award for her.

 

B-6.     Recognize the Outstanding 2005-06 Business Partners of the Year

            Dr. DiPatri recognized the districts Outstanding Business Partners of the Year.  Being recognized for the large organization Business Partner of the Year was NASA, represented by Andrew Bradley.  NASA is a business partner to Rockledge High School.  Being recognized for the small organization Business Partner of the Year was Precision Contemporary Dance, represented by Marty Eyster.  Precision Contemporary Dance is a business partner to McNair Magnet School.  Also recognized as the non-profit Business Partner of the Year was Palm Bay Rotary, represented by Mike Hazlett.  Palm Bay Rotary is a business partner to Palm Bay Elementary School.

 

B-8.     Recognition for the Brevard Cultural Alliance Excellence in Visual Arts Award

            Dr. DiPatri introduced Peggy Nolan, Arts Resource Teacher, who recognized art programs for receiving the Brevard Cultural Alliance Excellence in Visual Arts Award. Audubon Elementary, Challenger 7 Elementary, Gemini Elementary, Jupiter Elementary, Manatee Elementary, R.L. Stevenson School of the Arts, Astronaut High and Satellite High Schools.  Honorable mention:  Roy Allen Elementary.  Teachers who will receive the award will receive a plaque, $1,000.00 for their art program, $500.00 for themselves, and a banner for their schools.  Kendall Moore, Secretary and Board Member of the Brevard Cultural Alliance, assisted Ms. Nolan with the presentations.  Ms. Nolan also introduced June Hinckley, Fine Arts Specialist with the Department of Education, Alice Landry, Brevard Cultural Alliance, and Kathy Engerran, Brevard Cultural Alliance.

 

C.        RESOLUTIONS/PROCLAMATIONS/SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS

C-1.     Proclamation – Civility in the Month of May

            Sara Stern, Director of District Communications, read the proclamation to adopt May as Civility Month.  A motion was made by Larry Hughes with a second by Janice Kershaw to adopt the proclamation.  Motion carried unanimously.  A copy of the proclamation is filed in supplemental minute book #214, page 214-2.

 

D.        PUBLIC DISCUSSION

The Chair reminded the public that there is three minute per speaker set aside for discussion.  He also stated that the Board would not respond to issues this evening but the Superintendent would investigate and respond in a timely manner.  The following persons addressed the Board:

 

1.       Anne Spencer, BFT, Rockledge – Comparison of Teacher Hourly Rates with other Districts

2.       Tom Kelly, Cocoa – General classroom conduct

3.       Ron Thorstad, Titusville – Brevard Nature Alliance

 

 

 

 

CONSENT AGENDA (No Information Item at Prior Meeting)

A motion was made by Larry Hughes with a second by Janice Kershaw to approve Items E-1 through E-17.  Motion carried unanimously.  The below listed items were therefore approved.

 

E-1.     Student Expulsion(s)

Approve student expulsion(s) 2006-91, 2006-92, 2006-93, 2006-94, 2006-95, 2006-96, 2006-97, 2006-98, 2006-99, 2006-100, 2006-101, 2006-102, 2006-103, 2006-104, 2006-105, 2006-106, 2006-107, 2006-108, 2006-109, 2006-110 and 2006-111 for failure to comply with the Stipulation/Conduct Agreement and issue Final Orders confirming expulsion in each case presented.

 

E-2.     Approve Minutes

            Approve minutes from the expulsion hearing held on April 11, 2006, the minutes from the regular meeting held on April 11, 2006, the minutes from the special workshop held on April 19, 2006, and the minutes from the special meeting held on April 25, 2006.

 

E-3.     Budget Amendment #5 for the Operating Fund, 2005-06

            Approve resolution #5 to amend the Operating Fund budget by a decreased amount of $26,318, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-3 through 214-19, inc.

 

E-4.     Warrant List – March 1, 2006 Through March 31, 2006

            Approve the Warrant List for the period of March 1, 2006 through March 31, 2006, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-20 through 214-21, inc. Total expenditures were $33,592,028.77.

 

E-5.     Financial Statement – July 1, 2005 through March 31, 2006

            Approve the Financial Statement for July 1, 2005 through March 31, 2006, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-22 through 214-70, inc.

 

E-6.     Purchasing Bids, RFPs, RFQs, Sales & Service Agreements

            Award the Purchasing Bids listed below:

a.       #06-042/BP – Temporary Personnel Services – Human Resources – 2005/06

b.       #06-044/BP – Video Recorders – Transportation Services – 2005/06

c.       #06-050/BM – Lime Rock for Palm Bay High School Football Field – Palm Bay High School – 2005-06

 

            Copies of the bid tabulations are filed in the Purchasing Department office.

 

E-7.     Surplus Property

            Authorize the removal from inventory and disposal of surplus property according to prescribed procedures in Florida Statutes 274.05 and 274.06, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-71 through 214-82, inc.

 

E-8.     Administrative and Professional Reappointment Nominations for 2006-2007 School Year

            Approve the Superintendent’s administrative and professional reappointment nominations for the 2006-2007 school year, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-83 through 214-90, inc.

 

E-9.     Reappointment Nominations of Teachers for 2006-2007 School Year

            Approve the instructional nominations for the 2006-2007 school year contingent upon completion of certification requirements, course work, and/or the Florida Teacher Exam, on or before their beginning date, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-91 through 214-184, inc.

 

E-10.   Reappointment Nominations of Support Staff for 2006-2007 School Year

            Approve the reappointment nominations of support staff for the 2006-2007 school year, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-185 through 214-342, inc.

 

E-11.   Instructional Staff Recommendations

            Approve the transfer of Margaret DA. Neufeld from the position of Dean/Assistant Principal (10 month) at Satellite High School to the position of Dean/Assistant Principal (10 month) at Viera High School, on annual contract, effective August 2, 2006.  Annual salary based on grade 25 of the Nonbargaining Salary Administration Program.  Approve the routine instructional staff recommendations, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-343 through 214-350, inc.

 

E-12.   Support Staff Recommendations

            Approve the routine support staff recommendations, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-351 through 214-353, inc.

 

E-13.   Job Description

            Approve the following job description and grade:  Project Administration Specialist I, Pay Grade Core 1010 – 24, and Project Administration Specialist II, change in title only due to newly created career ladder, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-354 through 214-358, inc.

 

E-14.   Permission for Odyssey of the Mind (OM) Teams to Travel to World Finals

            Approve the request to travel to Odyssey of the Mind World finals on May 24 – May 27, 2006 at Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa.

 

E-15.   Permission for Future Problem Solving (FPS) Students to Travel to International Future Problem Solving Competition

            Approve the request to travel to International Future Problem Solving (FPS) competition in Fort Collins, Colorado, June 1-4, 2006.

 

E-16.   L.B. Johnson Middle School’s Community Future Problem Solvers (CFPS) students to Attend International FPS Competition in Forth Collins, Colorado, from June 1-4, 2006

            To approve the field trip for the CFPS (FPS) team from Johnson Middle School to travel to Ft. Collins, Colorado to participate in the FPS competition.

 

E-17.   Viera High School – FPL Easement – Two (2) for Main Campus and Stadium/Lift Station

            Approve the 10’ wide electrical facilities easements (2) for Florida Power & Light at Viera High School Main Campus and Stadium/Lift Station.  Copies of the easements are filed in the Facilities Management Services office.

 

---------

 

Dr. DiPatri took this opportunity to congratulate the instructional personnel listed under Item E-11.

 

----------

 

CONSENT AGENDA (Information Item at Prior Meeting)

Janice Kershaw requested Item F-3 be pulled.  A motion was then made by Janice Kershaw with a second by Larry Hughes to accept the recommendations for Items F-1 through F-2 and Items F-4 through F-21.  Motion carried unanimously. The below listed items were therefore approved.

 

F-1.      Adult/Community Education – South Area Lease Agreement

            Approve the Lease Agreement for the South Area Adult/Community Education Center, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-359 through 214-366, inc.

 

F-2.      Approve the 2006-07 Cooperative Agreement with Recording for the Blind and Dyslexic (RFB&D)

            Approve the Cooperative Agreement between the School Board of Brevard County, Florida and Recording for the Blind and Dyslexic (RFB&D “learning through listening”) not to exceed $34,000.00, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-367 through 214-372, inc.

 

F-4.      Department of Juvenile Justice 2006-2007 School Calendar

            Approve the 2006-2007 School Calendar for the Juvenile Justice Sites, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-373 through 214-374, inc.

 

F-5.      Educational Services Contract, Brevard Public Schools and Hurricane Island Outward Bound

            Approve the Agreement between the School Board of Brevard County and Hurricane Island Outward Bound in the amount of $46,585.00 for educational services, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-375 through 214-386, inc.

 

F-6.      Brevard Public Schools and Space Coast Marine Institute, Contract for Educational Services

            Approve the Agreement between Brevard Public Schools and Space Coast Marine Institute in the amount of $232,132.00, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-387 through 214-400, inc.

 

 

 

F-7.      Contract for Educational Services between Brevard Public Schools and Center for Drug Free Living for Brevard Group Treatment Home

            Approve the Agreement between the School Board and Center for Drug Free Living (for the Brevard Group Treatment Home) in the amount of $160,635.00, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-401 through 214-413, inc.

 

F-8.      Contract for Educational Services between Brevard Public Schools and Center for Drug Free Living for Frances Walker Halfway House

            Approve the Agreement between the School Board and Center for Drug Free Living (for Frances Walker Halfway House) in the amount of $155,406.00, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-414 through 214-426, inc.

 

F-9.      Agreement:  School Board of Brevard County and Kids Medical Club

            Approve the Agreement between the School Board of Brevard County and Kids Medical Club for an estimated amount of $60,000.00 for one teacher, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-427 through 214-431, inc.

 

F-10.    Agreement:  School Board of Brevard County and the National Deaf Academy

            Approve the Agreement between the School Board of Brevard County and the National Deaf Academy in the amount of $161,512.50 for residential placement of one Brevard County student, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-432 through 214-442, inc.

 

F-11.    School Board of Brevard County and Crosswinds Youth Shelter, Contract for Educational Services

            Approve the Agreement between the School Board and Crosswinds Youth Shelter in the amount of $34,653.00, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-443 through 214-453, inc.

 

F-12.    School Board of Brevard County and Crosswinds/Rainwater Center for Girls, Contract for Educational Services

            Approve the Agreement between the School Board and Crosswinds/Rainwater Center for Girls in the amount of $66,513.00, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-454 through 214-467, inc.

 

F-13.    Center for Performance Assessment Workshop – Classroom Instruction That Works

            Approve agreement with Center for Performance Assessment for one day workshop for elementary Title I teachers on “Effective Teaching Strategies for the Standards-Based Classroom”, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-468 through 214-469, inc.  This workshop will be one of five offered as part of the week-long professional development academy for Title I teachers – Reaching the Summit – Tools for Teaching and Learning.

 

F-14.    Achieving Rigor and Relevance in the Elementary Classroom

            Approve agreement with The International Center for Leadership in Education to present a one day workshop on Achieving Rigor and Relevance in the Elementary Classroom, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-470 through 214-473, inc.  This workshop will be one of five offered as part of the week-long professional development academy for Title I teachers – Reaching the Summit – Tools for Teaching and Learning.

 

F-15.    Dr. Tom Guskey – Assessment As Learning – The Instructional Role of Assessment

            Approve agreement with Dr. Tom Guskey for presenting a one day workshop on Assessment as Learning – The Instructional Role of Assessment, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-474 through 214-475, inc.  This workshop will be one of five offered as part of the week-long professional development academy for Title I teachers – Reaching the Summit – Tools for Teaching and Learning.

 

F-16.    Understanding the Pre-Adolescent and Impact on Classroom Behaviors – Dr. David Walsh

            Approve agreement with Dr. David Walsh for a one-day workshop on Understanding the Pre-Adolescent Brain.  This workshop will be one of five offered as part of the week-long professional development academy for Title I teachers – Reaching the Summit – Tools for Teaching and Learning.

 

F-17.    Kagan Structures for Success

            Approve agreement with Kagan Professional Development for the Structures for Success workshop, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-476 through 214-478, inc.  This workshop will be one of five offered as part of the week-long professional development academy for Title I teachers – Reaching the Summit – Tools for Teaching and Learning.

 

F-18.    Thinking Maps, Inc.

            Approve agreement with Thinking Maps, Inc. for a one day workshop for elementary Title I teachers, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-479 through 214-480, inc.  This workshop will be one of five offered as part of the week-long professional development academy for Title I teachers – Reaching the Summit – Tools for Teaching and Learning.

 

F-19.    Contracted Services Agreement between Sunrise Elementary School and Mr. Rick. Inc.

            Approve the contracted services agreement between Sunrise Elementary School and Mr. Rick, Inc. to provide a motivational program for students based on Character Education and starting a “New Beginning” on August 11, 2006,

 

F-20.    Consultant Agreement with Don Bizzell

            Approve the consultant agreement with Don Bizzell to provide training of the State Requirements for Educational Facilities Course for fifteen to twenty School Board Employees currently working in Plant Operations and Maintenance or Facilities Services.  The total cost for the training shall not exceed $3,000.00.

 

F-21.    Prototype Design Services for New Elementary School “T”

            Select the BRPH Architects-Engineers prototype elementary design for Elementary School “T”, as filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-481 through 214-487, inc.

 

ITEMS PULLED FOR DISCUSSION

F-3.      2006-07 Agreement with Brevard Achievement Center (BAC) to Serve Exceptional Education Students

            Approve the Agreement with the Brevard Achievement Center (BAC) to provide services to eligible ESE students in the amount not to exceed $434,600.00.

 

            Janice Kershaw requested this item be pulled and stated that since she is employed by the Brevard Achievement Center, she had a conflict with this particular item.  She then read into the record a Memorandum of Voting Conflict, a copy of which is filed in supplemental minute book #214, pages 214-488 through 214-498, inc.

 

            A motion was then made by Larry Hughes with a second by Bea Fowler to approve the recommendation.  Motion carried by a unanimous vote of 4 with Janice Kershaw abstaining from voting.

 

----------

 

The Chair called for a BPS News video break at 6:30 p.m.

The meeting reconvened at 6:43 p.m.

 

----------

 

G.        ACTION AGENDA

G-1.     Proposed Amendment with Brevard County Commission Regarding Charter School Educational Impact Fees

            Approve the Superintendent’s recommendation regarding a proposed agreement between the School Board and the Brevard County Board of County Commissioners concerning educational impact fees for charter schools and authorize transmittal of same to County Commission.

 

            A motion was made by Larry Hughes with a second by Janice Kershaw to approve the recommendation. 

 

            Janice Kershaw noted that this was a financial issue and had no bearing on the merits of Odyssey Charter School.  She stated that the Legislature gave discretion to County Commissions to divert funds to charter schools but did not provide any direction for this distribution. She questioned whether Odyssey Charter School was eligibility to receive funds because the building was conceived and built before the law was enacted.  She stated she felt the Superintendent’s recommendation met the spirit of the Interlocal Agreement.  Ms. Kershaw asked the Superintendent to look into the legality of making a loan to the school at 0% interest.

 

Amy Kneessy stated she could not support the recommendation because she felt it was unfair to base the allocation only on Bayside Lakes students.  She questioned if the County Commission could change the agreement that both parties had agreed to.  Board Attorney Harold Bistline stated that the Interlocal Agreement was signed by both parties and was based on mutual respect and cooperation.

Dr. DiPatri stated that an exclusive agreement was not in the original  contract that Odyssey had entered in to with Bayside Lakes.  He stated that there are 410 total students from the Bayside Lakes Development but only 35 are attending Odyssey.  He also stated that staff had requested a copy of the waiting list of students but has not been able to obtain this as yet.

 

Larry Hughes voiced his support, questioned if the charter school was even eligible for impact fees and stated the figure should be based on the number of students actually attending.

 

Harold Bistline explained that impact fees are reviewed by a committee made up of governmental representatives who look at the amount of fees collected and the needs of the school district.  The committee then makes a recommendation to the school board on how to spend these funds.  He also explained that a charter school should petition the school board that they would like to mitigate a development.  The board then decides if it is an approved use of the charter school and the County Commission has the discretion to allocate, per that development, to the charter.  This was amended in 2004 by the Legislature and was effective July 1, 2004.

 

Bea Fowler stated she felt they needed advise from the State and the item should be deferred until they get that direction.

 

Discussion was held on whether or not there are 40 students on a waiting list and if those students should be counted in the formula. Dr. DiPatri questioned why they would have a waiting list if the charter school had an exclusive agreement with Bayside Lakes Development.

 

Janice Kershaw and Larry Hughes voiced their opinions that the School Board should be supportive of the effort and move forward.  Larry Hughes stated he would like to see the board approve the recommendation unanimously and send to the County Commission to make them make a decision.  If the County does not agree, the next step would be to litigate.  Amy Kershaw again stated she could not support the recommendation without adding the 40 students on the waiting list to the formula.

 

At this point, the Chairman called for the vote.

 

Voting aye:  Larry Hughes, Robert Jordan, Janice Kershaw

Voting nay:  Amy Kneessy, Bea Fowler

Motion carried by a vote of 3 to 2

 

G-2.     Lewis Carroll Elementary School

            Recommend the consideration of a new elementary school of 500 students on School Board property on State Road 3, Merritt Island, north of the Barge Canal to relieve overcrowding at Lewis Carroll Elementary School.  It is also recommended that the Proposed Project List in the district’s Seven Year Facility Improvement Plan be revised to include the project “for consideration in January 2007”.  At that time, the proposed school would be placed on a timeline in priority order with all other proposed new school projects.  A copy of the latest membership summary showing the number of students attending Lewis Carroll Elementary School who live north and south of the Barge Canal is provided as Attachment I.

 

            A motion was made by Larry Hughes with a second by Bea Fowler to approve the recommendation.  Motion carried unanimously.

 

            Bea Fowler expressed her concern with the situation at the school before construction could begin and suggested that staff come up with some suggestions.  She also stated that she had received an e-mail from a parent with a concern of a one hour earlier dismissal time due to long bus routes.  Dr. DiPatri asked her to forward the e-mail to him and he would look into it.

 

INFORMATION AGENDA

H-1.     Easy Benefits Contract Renewal

            Recommendation:  Approve annual renewal effective July 1, 2006 of the contract with Easy Benefits LLC for employee benefits data management and the Online Job Center support.

 

H-2.     Renew the School Boards Property and Casualty Insurance